Skip to content
GRE Psychology overview

Worked example

Free to read

Negative reinforcement or punishment?

Classify a consequence from what changes in the environment and what happens to the behaviour afterward.

Question

An unpleasant reminder tone stops when a learner begins their scheduled practice. Over the next week, the learner begins practice more often when the tone sounds. Which process best describes this change?

  1. a.Positive reinforcement
  2. b.Negative reinforcement
  3. c.Positive punishment
  4. d.Negative punishment

Correct answer

B. Negative reinforcement

Full reasoning

  1. 1Name the target behaviour precisely: beginning practice when the tone sounds.
  2. 2Identify the consequence: the tone is removed. “Negative” refers to removal, not to whether the situation feels bad.
  3. 3Identify the observed direction of change: beginning practice becomes more frequent. That makes this reinforcement.
  4. 4Combine the two dimensions: removal plus increased behaviour is negative reinforcement. The intended purpose of the tone alone would not be enough; the observed behaviour matters.

Why each choice is right or wrong

Choice A

No pleasant stimulus is described as being added after the behaviour.

Choice B

Correct. An unpleasant tone is removed, and beginning practice becomes more frequent.

Choice C

The consequence is removal rather than addition, and the behaviour increases rather than decreases.

Choice D

Removing something counts as negative punishment only when it reduces the target behaviour.

Related formula

Related topic and practice

This worked example is free to read. A free account unlocks practice questions for this exam.

Sources

Original authored exercise; no database question ID and no protected or official exam-bank content. Specialist review pending.

  1. Psychology 2e, Section 6.3: Operant ConditioningOpenStax. Accessed 2026-08-03. OpenStax textbook content is CC BY-NC-SA 4.0; attribute and avoid verbatim reuse beyond short cited references.
Share this worked solution

Sources and corrections

Sources last checked 2026-09-13

Every source cited on this page was checked on the date shown, and we update the page when a source changes. If something looks wrong, tell us and we'll recheck it.